What is your server preference?

I didn't mind No-Soup, I just hated the op structures.
Nerf please.

 

You really think people would want to spend time "learning?" Souping is flat out hard and it takes too much time to prep for. And you stated most of the "MCPVP" community were soupers. This is the Brawl community, therefore there are lots of people who do not know how to soup. Heck, the wouldn't even want to learn. It's hard, and I don't want to keep switching hotkeys every 2 seconds. It's flat out stressful, also, people would just want to play HG simply. A lot of people find learning boring, and they would rather play no-soup. No-soup is fun for everyone. By everyone, even people that cannot soup. Soup should be the substitute for people that want to play HG differently. No-soup is the main gamemode for everyone. Soup should be the "Challenge HG" type since you use soup. What I'm saying is, No-soup should be the primary one. For example, if you go to the portal, the middle portal is no-soup, and the side portals are soup, for the people that know how to soup and they want to get a bigger challenge since theyll be fighting other people that know how to soup instead of people who do not know.

 

Stopped reading right there - I didn't want the sheer ignorance of that post to contaminate me.

 

I'm not saying it's dumb I'm saying it's hard and challenging. Souping isn't like that. You can't just make people play your favorite game type by telling people who don't know how to soup: "Learn to soup bub." Thats basically what you're telling them. If a lot of people cannot soup and want no-soup as their primary game, let them. This is not MCPVP anymore. This is Brawl. Everyone does not know how to soup here, so give them a game where soup is nothing to worry about.

 

Then why did you say it was "flat-out dumb" if you didn't intend to say it's dumb? (You edited after I quoted your post.)

I also wouldn't generalize. Not everyone hates games that require practice to reach the skillcap.

 

Because the person above me ticked me off when he said, "learn to soup." Like any Brawl players want to learn. Learning to soup takes time, and what better way to spend that time by playing no-soup. Why learn? Play no-soup. Soup should be considered as the "Challenge HG" for people who know how to soup.

 

Uw0tm8? Souping is hard? Get Nosoup Kitbrawl out now!!1!

 

Yes, it's hard. Hotkeying back and forth every 1-2 seconds is hard. No-soup is much more fun. In no-soup, you get to rely on your kits more than soup. In soup, we take out kits for granted, and we focus more on soup. There are over 100 kits! Make use with them, don't soup. Like I said, No-Soup should remain primary and Soup should be considered a challenge gamemode.

 

Games take time to learn. Why start playing minecraft if you don't know how it works? Please.

 

Minecraft? All you have to do is check the controls. Easy. I learned to play in 10 minutes. Souping takes a lot more time. Minecraft is all about having fun. No-soup is for people who do not want to learn how to soup and want to have fun.

And why learn if there's a game for people that do not want to learn? You know, a lot more people play No-soup than Soup. Soup is for the people that are good at souping, or if they are well with it.

Soup is basically saying, "You can only play if you know how to soup." Brawl shouldn't restrict a game so it only benefits people who know how to soup. They should have no-soup as the primary HG server, for it benefits both soupers, and no-soupers. Soup should still be in Brawl, but it should be the secondary HG server, and seen as a challenge gamemode. Soup should be a challenge for people who know how to soup. If you would like to play no-soup, it'll remain the main HG server for everyone.

 

And there you go - you're generalizing. If every Brawl player hates learning, then how come some people joined MCPVP and decided to stay there and learn how things work?

 

But what happened? MCPVP popularity died. It takes more time to learn how to soup than to learn how to get good with a kit. I'm trying tk say that no-soup should be the main HG server. Like, No-soup is the large portal in the HG spawn. Soup can be the side portals for people that want a challenge. No-soup should be the main server for people who do not like souping, or cannot soup. With the soup servers on the side, they should be the challenge portion of HG for the soupers that want to see a real challenge.

 

Why do you think so many people learned to soup back when HG was super popular...

 

You're trying to make it so that no-soup has little-no fame and all the people who want to play soup HG MUST learn how to soup.

Because that was the only gamemode and people were FORCED to soup. When no-soup came out, more people played no soup, and all the people who played soup stayed to play soup HG while no-soup was primary.

Look at the votes. Do you see how many like no-soup? All these people would rather play no-soup because they find it much more fun.

 

Or people played no soup because 1 they didn't know how to get to soup and 2 there were more people on no soup.

 

Exactly! That's why more people like no-soup. It got much more popularity when it came out. If it goes to Brawl, no-soup will be enjoyed by HUNDREDS. It could be THOUSANDS.

 

Why not have the best of both words and just have both servers running with none favored over the other?

 

Probs because people who played soup don't use the forums or are nice enough to let no soup get some recognition too.

 

That could work.

If they would like it to get recognition, they would've voted for 15 minutes alternate.

Look, it should be both. 1 portal - No-soup

1 portal - soup

That can benefit both soupers and no-soupers.

 

Or half of them voted for soup and the other for alternate...