Accepted WitherKitty's WE2 application

Changing to WE2.

Pending, going to leave this up for a couple more days.

 

All right, I wasn't too sure if I should've said this before... However, now that you bring up all these complaints, I feel like I should go right ahead and say what I really wanted to say.

First, I have no idea why you'd put quotations on the word helpful, since the thread I created about MCBuild was supposed to be helpful to others and has helped a lot of people (including yourself). I apologize if you feel that I am biased, though I don't know what you mean by that. When it comes to rank applications, especially higher ranks, I tend to judge harshly and I'm sorry if you have problems with that. You shouldn't be comparing how I am when creating threads/comments for or about MCBuild, and how I am when creating threads/comments for Creative. The way I am when judging rank application isn't the same as me creating threads to help others out. Yes, my replies on applications may be harsh but they do help the applicant since it's called a constructive criticism. You should be able to take my constructive criticisms in order to show that you can be responsible around the worst situations.

There is a quote button that you can use from Skype, but you would have to ask me for permission if you want to post it on a public thread since it's called a private message for a reason. However, what I wrote on Skype and what I wrote on the application are not contradictory and I was not the one who encouraged you to go for WEPro. What I said on Skype was:
"Well, you don't want to be just using world edit to build for higher ranks. You need to show others that you are capable of building great builds without the help of world edit. Then, when you have a decently looking work, you can use it on the application (even though it may be unfinished) saying that you need World Edit for the specific build that you are working on one of the big plots"

Spoiler: In case any of yall want proof

I made sure that Wither's replies were covered since I couldn't ask her for permission whether I was allowed to use this picture or not. So here is what I wrote to her if you are wondering.

What I said wasn't really an encouragement towards you to go for WEPro. The only things I said were how you would have to be if you were to skip ranks. I apologize if you misunderstood what I told you.

Yes, what you said is almost all 100% true. But it's because there is no PERFECT application. Someone might have a superb application with not so good builds. Some others might have amazing builds with the worst application. There are a lot, you get the idea. However, everything you are currently saying, all translate to: "I want WEPro before the merge.", "I want WEPro to look like I really worked hard.", and/or "I want WEPro for the status." in my opinion. That's just what I think, though.

Also, may I just say, how immature of you to think that because I am your friend, I have to give you a positive feedback on your application. I don't judge applications unfairly. I like to judge rank applications seriously, because that's who I am. If you cannot take constructive criticisms, you are not ready. At this point, I would say you do not deserve WE2 as well. I like how you removed me from Skype just because of this situation. I wish you the best of luck in the future when you apply for anything.

 

No offense but you said its an achievement and a honor that is worked for. I don't believe you worked for it at all your builds are small and you don't have any full plots so you cant say you need plots when you have 5. You also say too be judged by peers but we are judging it and you come back as though you are insulted or if your jealous or angry about it. And world edit should be given too people with massive wall too wall world edit builds that are detailed. If you think other wise okay but I think they should be given world edit. And I have never seen or heard of helping someone. I have seen someone ask in shout and you said no actually and so you don't help so are you lying?

There isn't a need too try and flame in this about a application. And @Potatoto actually helped a lot of people with that post. Including yourself cause you can see who all has checked that post. And in this you say you made opinions on those applications...Okay everyone does actually but how exactly does that help your application? And your first reason isn't great on this because I know many people trying too actually get WE do put in a lot of length and time into it, And you can never have too many builds but you don't want too keep posting the same exact builds over and ovr again. And your builds can never be too big but as you get more and more ranks and apply for more you need bigger better builds. Like we need proof that you have improved on building or you wont get it. And your 5th reason is really off. No one says that in comments unless they have no idea how too grade an application. I know myself I don't do that and neither do any wepros or WE2s.

 

I beg to differ, because your dragon head was a tutorial... you just changed the blocks...

 

App: +1
Maturity: +0.5
Builds: +0
The builds aren't original...
OVERALL: +0

 

o.5

 

I believe Tato is correct on this,wanting the rank for "YOLO" isn't a good reason. The builds are good, but not great some of them lack detail. The proof provided confirms you're the owner of the plot, but there's alot of people added did any of them help you out while building? I like the app and all the detail, but it seems to go off topic a bit. I don't know you too well so I can't rate you on maturity . Overall +0 for now add some more detail to your builds and you'll have my +1.

 

You've changed my mind, sorry for giving you a bad score. +1

 

I did not say that you are immature for removing me and unfriending me or for doing or saying anything outside of Brawl. I said, "How immature of you to think that because I am your friend, I have to give you a positive feedback on your application." Meaning that you thought I was going to give you a definite yes just because we are friends. If you think that your friends are supposed to be giving you a yes on your application even if it's not good enough, you are not "mature" enough.

"I thought we were friends".

Sounds pretty immature to me. I apologize you keep understanding my replies in a wrong way. I'll try to be more clear next time. Anywho, my choice has been made and it will not be changed. -1

 

WitherKitty you are trying really hard to argue with us and other members of brawl to get us to change our votes. And @Potatoto Shouldn't have to give you a definite yes because she is your friend. So Im not going too change my vote at all even if you have a good reason to cause in these comments there is literal proof of your immaturity.

 

There is a way you could change no votes to yes votes. When I had my WEPro application up, I had a few no votes but I managed to change them. If you want to see how I worked on changing the votes, look at pages 2, 3 and maybe 4 of my application. What you're trying to do to change your votes is not the smartest way. Best of luck with the application, Wither.

 

+1
Good luck

 

Application: +1
-Very long
-Very detailed
-It seems you like you know what the rank provides

Builds: +1
-Definitely worthy for WE2
-Seems like it took you a lot of time
-Very detailed

Overall: +1
I think you're ready for this!

 

I agree