Poll: Phoenix HG or No-Soup HG

WHAT DO YOU HAVE AGAINST NO SOUP HG

 

I like the Starting feast in the middle. Other than that, i feel like it hurts the point of it. Too many structures and what not.

 

I like Phoenix. It feels like SG with natural terrain and the ability to break blocks. Maybe this can attract some old SG/SGG players

 

Wow... No skill???

Okay not to sound bratty but I know for a fact there is a LOT of skill to it. You should be scared of every little thing that hurts you. There is a lot of skill involved, just not muscle memory skill with souping. If the game takes skill then you should be able to win every game?

 

Some people literally do win everytime they play it.

 

I win most of the time I play no-soup, so it gets boring rather quickly. The only time I have fun on no-soup is by doing something silly and still wining.

 

You definitely are not guaranteed to win No-Soup everytime.

As TheMafias said, you have to be wary of everything. By the same argument, you should be able to win Soup every time as well, as a new player will now be able to beat and experienced player, whereas in No-Soup, the reverse is true if they catch you at an opportune moment for them.

 

I said most of the time, not all of the time. Plus, I only play no-soup at most once a week, so I have a more imbalanced win/loss ratio.

 

I liked the aspects of Phoenix in that it was very fast paced and that there was a feast right at the beginning. This made it so you would have to make quick decisions of whether or not to loot feast items or hope for structure items. The only thing that made it a bit unappealing in my opinion was that it was solely whoever could get to the structures first, and find more.

I think it'd be an interesting spin on nosoup but I don't know if it's the solution.

 

If not for the fact that I don't take no soup seriously, I would win every game. In fact, I won a game starting off with a wooden hoe. The rare times I take it seriously, I win, which shows that it takes no skill

 

I am sorry but it really does take skill... You do not win every game. Maybe a lot of games but not every game. I myself have kill you but to win you do need to be careful of EVERYTHING

 

I'm speaking about no soup. I don't take it seriously, so that's why you've killed me in no soup. If I tried to win a game, I would.

Example: I'm low on health. If I took it seriously, I would run and dig to heal my hearts. But since I don't, I keep fighting

 

If you don't take it seriously why even play it or complain about it? People like it a lot and so do I, it is a completely new game play style and I like it.

 

I watched it and it seems like it has too many chest which kills item kits and digging kits. That's what bothers me the most.

 

There aren't any kits in PheonixHg

 

OH SCREW THAT. I HATE SOUP PVP AND I AM NOT LOSING MY KITS.... HECK TO THE NO

 

There are kits, it's just that the kits were customizable similar to McPVP's Mazerunner. If this were to ever become a thing we likely wouldn't do this, we'd probably stick to whatever vanilla kits we had in NoSoup HG.