Sheriff Idea

This suggestion sounds like you play on another server and are already used to their guns and want to bring them here. Describing it in terms of "its like the one on that server I play" isn't really helpful to us.

In my opinion, Sheriffs should be able to kill a Full Diamond player in 1 shot fewer than the player (with illegals) can kill a kevlar'd sheriff, but no gun should be able to one-shot a target from 10 to 0.
If that's ^ not the current balance, it is rather close to it.

 

As a sheriff, I can say that the guns are fifty fifty.

If you happen to find CROW camping at a WG, with 4 people all with models, Mausers, and Carcanos, you would not say that they are overpowered. Now don't get me wrong I do think that you shouldn't be able to one shot diamonds. I don't think though that any sort of major nerf is needed.

Most of the "It's OP" comes from the one guy at a processed, but for the most part sheriff is fine.

 

I was a bandit at one point, but that's not the point of this thread.

Anyway, I feel that the Sheriff guns are fine, but maybe make the Damage drop off a little more prominent in the Coach.

 

To my knowledge, the repeater matches the Gewher in strength, so I think it's fine. The Carcano is pitifully weak. A gun with slightly more damage and a lot lower rof would simply be too great of a nerf.

I will agree with you that the shotgun is OP. If anything, the damage should be nerfed. I think more players would complain that sheriffs got an automatic weapon than they do currently about the shotgun.

 

I think you missed the point of my post: vaguely saying "it will have a faster fire rate than this other server's gun" is useless.

 

You can do a slight chance like nerf sheriff guns by one point of damage and see how it works, if still complaining, slight chance once again and so on.

Honestly, since I joined a team, I've been having trouble with sheriffs, more times getting arrested or shot.

 

What I think needs done is a damage drop off. I'm not sure if they already have this, but basically it makes it so the farther the target is, the less damage you do.

I also think that the spray should be slightly increased with the Coach. I mean, it is a shotgun, and you should if you're a few feet away,

Then comes the repeater. I honestly don't know. I think that the 1 hit kill bug has to be removed. Besides that, don't know what else to do.

Why does no one every talk about the Pistol? Honestly one of the best weapons. It is a spray cannon, and I've raked up quite the kill streak with it.

 

I say keep the spread and nerf the damage. I love that things spread too much. It's what makes it unique. If the damage was nerfed enough, the lack of spread could be used against sheriffs by model users.