mandatory proof of proof

The old staff system used to be way better, where if someone appealed a ban, the mod who banned the player (if it was a controversial ban) would provide proof + explanation for the ban to be 100% justified. It used to be very transparent, but now there's too many clouds in between the players and staff.

TLDR; staff need to show proof to an appealing player against the ban unless it was blatant. Why the **** not.

 

its really not hard. just upload all the videos to an anonymous brawl hacker channel make sure any names are blocked out to maintain anonymity. cmon guys nothings changed, if someone REALLY wanted to ddos/dox someone when presented proof, the person would have gotten the whole staff team and booted them at the same time and it has been done in the past.

its crazy how long it takes because theres absolutely no structure in this staff team.

care to input, or do your job in any way shape/form?

 

but the issue with this is that regardless if you upload the fight or not, any banned player will remember the point they are banned from. usually before they get banned they are mocked by the player and/or team of the player and even so if i get called out for blink by one team when i was actually lagging/grappling (believe me, ive been banned by both) id certainly remember all details of the fight. Uploaded proof or not shouldnt stop a player from targetting other players at all. and if a staff uploads in poof just block out any proof that it was that staff member and then it shouldnt be a problem against that staff member since its all anonymous.

yes but thats the point of this thread. what if the player didnt actually commit those actions yet is appealing ? and no im not talking about anyone specifically. its happened to me many times before and of course the staff team was always in the wrong yet it took weeks for me to get unbanned. it just takes so damn long compared to how long it used to take to resolve issues as such

 

nothing will stop that anyway. a few bad apples shouldn't cost the whole community their right to review evidence to their own actions. its even in the constitution in real punishments that the defendant can see evidence. obviously this isnt real life, its mc, but it goes to show that its far more productive/fair in real life, why not do it here?

also it used to be like that as well. back when there was 1.5k players on we still had to show proof. I remember once i false banned a kid for blink and he appealed demanding proof. I was forced to provide the proof and throughout my explanation realized it was ladder physics w/ shift, not blink and the mistake was corrected within a day.

 

so far ive only heard of this one "imingo" guy whose pulled that stunt, where are all the other cases? the server gets 200 people on average a day and that happened just as often now as it did back when i was staff. with over 1k players

 

12 by the way

he didnt post **** lol quit lying to yourself. he sent it privately in a private ts and the list had no working IPs.

he's talking about the initial permanent ban, if you were active enough and did your job you'd realize we've been having this conversation for over 2 months.