Complete [CTF] Ever Grande City

I rate -3/10, since I wasn't there. Other than that problem, it's 10/10.

 

9.5/10 I just didn't like the blending between the rock outcrop and the terrain...

 

9/10, I'll say that the one part underground needed something more direct to get to that sponge... if you know what I mean xD

 

I would say archer op and it's hard for noobs to climb the hill in the middle but nice

 

looks fantabulous

 

So far, the map looks good, I just looked at the pictures, not the map (Because you banned me from it -_-)
However I see some problems with the map as follows:

• By the looks of it, the underground has minimal terrain and is very crowded in some places. Although well done.
• Game-play wise, the surface is good.... But those trees I'm having second thoughts about, they don't look that detail (Try to replace the wood with different variations of "log:# (ex. 13)", which will have the bark on each side of the block.)
• The flag room is a bit large, making it op or camping. Maybe add some walls to the left and right of the flag itself?
• The map needs more overall cover above ground, maybe some sort of tower towards the middle? Maybe a house or two? But not too much, gotta make soldiers suffer, and heads able to be shot still.
• Make a very obvious way to get onto the roof via sponge, soldiers can sit there unharmed (From what I can tell.)

Lugia I know you don't like me, but I'm giving this to you to help better your map, whether it be constructive to you or not, it's my opinion. Also as my opinion, I feel like you aren't spending enough time on your maps, as if you were neglecting them. And the neglect has lead me to post this. My recommendation? Spend more than 2 days on a map... Maps take weeks, even months to make (Unless you're Shinxwinx.) A map is never really complete.

 

flag shootable (but difficult). easily fixable

very archer op. ill say my fix idea below

i would bring the bottom of the stone hill and the bottom of the grass hill to meet eachother around the red line. it makes it so that cave exits aren't as immediate in the way they come out the hill so it won't form as much as a choke point. plus it also means you could bring the caves forward, possibly out of headshot distance. it would also make the terraforming look nicer cuz atm it seems very steep and difficult to walk up, as well as the fact theres a very sudden transition between the two. u could fade it easier.

 

Terrible map. Not even worth a rating.

 

Amazing. I couldn't really find any major deal-breakers coming from this map in terms of gameplay. Archers will be especially strong in this map but it looks like there's enough cover/alternate routes to not make them a game-breaker. The only thing that needs to be added are sponges to get on top of the flag building, seeing that as of right now, I couldn't find any way to get up there via sponge/stairs/ladders. Overall though, keep it up. I really think your maps have potential to be in rotation one day.