Complete Matt's "Civil War" CTF: REQUESTING FEEDBACK

Those pictures show next to nothing. However, here's stuff I can get form them:

• Remove the hills surrounding the map, they can be abused by soldiers and ninjas.
• Shorten the heights of the building and provide more access to the roofs.
• Have an actual exit from spawn. Right now it's too cramped.
• If you aren't planning to anything with it, remove the grass part. It serves no purpose but to allow people to roam around away from the center of the map.
• Add an underground. It always enhances the map if it is well done.
• Widen the roads. They seem pretty cramped.

So yeah, can't really provide much feedback with the amount of information I have. Try to avoid building tall structures in maps. I would recommend hoping on CTF and checking out how gameplay flows and maps look. I don't know if you have much experience with CTF or CTF maps.

 

Agreed. This isn't too bad for a first try, but it could, as most maps do, use some work. Some tips for future maps:
-Avoid high sloping hills.
-If you're going to build buildings, only build 1-3 and make them no more than 25 blocks vertical
- Make your passageways between structures wide. You want allot of open space on a CTF map (but not open enough to allow easy archer head shots. Find a balance.
-Make the flag and spawn obvious. A newbie should be able to find the flag. Use logic: It's often in the biggest or centermost building.

 

Keep making maps. Don't stop trying.

 

Next time you make a map, plan the gameplay first. Aesthetics and theme are secondary. For this it just looks like you made a few buildings you were proud of and decided to convert them into a map.

CTF maps are excruciatingly difficult to get right so don't be disheartened, keep making maps.