Complete [CTF] Harvest

Wow, looks very good flavorous! I don't really need to critique because it looks pretty good in all aspects of it.

 

Multicolored fences... it's your signature.

 

Looks great! +1

 

Incredible, I think it is already going to be added c:

+1

 

Great map, like always! +1

 

Hey there Flav, pretty good job with the map so far. Unfortunately, there are still a number of issues with it at this point in time, such as:

Aesthetics:

First off, this is more of a complaint with this thread than the map itself, but please use something resembling a default texture pack when you're posting screenshots of your maps. The over-the-top night sky in the background is extremely distracting, and doesn't fit the style of the map in the slightest.


Also, you left a couple red banners on the blue flagroom. Just a minor thing, but it'd look silly if those stayed there. Anyhow, moving on to...

Gameplay Issues:

For starters, the flagroom should be fine as is, if leaning a bit towards favoring soldiers. No problem there.



The spawn box has a couple points that a ninja could theoretically pearl into and camp on. Also, there's no way onto the roof for most classes, so it'll be an easy camping spot if nothing's done to correct that.



These overhangs at mid have the same issue, with there being no way onto them outside of Ninja, Elf or Soldier, but the consequences of that are much more severe. Due to their placement, a Soldier/Elf would be able to cross mid without ever having to be vulnerable to less-mobile melee classes.


Same issue with these trees here. Starting to sense a trend?


Lastly, these trees at the back, while certainly pretty, are a nightmare for recovery. Again, there is no way to get to the top for less-mobile classes, and the spacing of the 'leaves' creates spots that cannot be headshotted. The trees are right next to spawn as well, allowing easy access to medics and further enabling flagholders to camp with impunity.

Summary:
The map has plenty of potential, but the issues with accessibility for some of the structures are way too game-breaking to ignore. -1 until those are fixed.

 

Just a question did Faw make those autumnish trees cos me and her made trees exactly like that idk.

 

i'd strongly recommend redesigning the flag room. you can basically instacap this map

imagine im a ninja; i can throw a pearl through either of those two windows then steal the flag

that'll land me around here:

which is right next to a sponge. use the sponge and then you can basically pearl straight into your own flag room


if you keep the flag room the way it is then ninjas are just going to end this map in 2 minutes which isn't fun

 

1*