Making a ctf resourcepack, want some opinions

Mhm, seems good but doesnt really seem like a ctf pack

 

These are not bad at all. Out of the 3 choices, I like the pickaxe the most.

Things I like:

- Connected parts and shapes work well together.
- Tone of the default colors. (Reminds me of classic fantasy games)
- Consistent theme in each, the gem.
​

Things I'd change:

- Too much noise on the blade/part of tool used.

-- add a light line to the edge of the axe, under belly of the pickaxe and full side of the sword or however you see fit. (detailed dimensions)​

- The sword outline isn't as clean as I feel it could be.
- The axes could be edited a pixel or two, to give more of a curve shape. 1-2 pixels can change a lot in pixel art.

c:​

 

The sword doesn't look sharp, like it goes in and out of being straight (though I understand, my explanation of this is not the best). With the axes, experiment with it. The bottom middle part of the axe blade could come out from the middle a tiny bit and the lower end of the blade could curve outwards as a tiny bit as well. 1-2 pixel edits that I could easily just change and show you, but where's the fun in that. <3

 

Make sugar or Redstone a creampuff. Or just make all the pots creampuffs!!

 

Gold and iron stuffs need 2 be more shiny! far too dull atm...
(at least they need hilights)

 

The iron sword just looks like its had a bad day, very rough, no clear lines, etc...
Looks more like a sword an archeologist dug up than something a Soldier in the middle ages would have carried out into battle.
This is what i mean by "shiny"....



The pickaxe is fine as is, since it might not be too "shiny" after a long times service down in the mines...

 

if u actually wanted to compliment the pack you would have ignored such an incredibly small thing instead of trying to take Pan down in any way possible

 

No, I just meant that the blade needs a bit of polishing since it looks somewhat like the blade showed below;

It should look more like this:


There is absolutely nothing wrong with the design however. It looks nice!

 

Would u mind that i try Make these weapons 3D?
Gj man ^,-

 

Ive taken myself some artistic freedom here but....

<--- maybe?

 

I'm no good with textures; is there any way to have a curved sword texture? Not in the pack, but in general. Is it possible to make one?