Idea A Whole New Kitbrawl

Instead of all of this, make a server with actual hit detection and not a sloppy joke of a server that an 8 year old could do better. I don't consider KitBrawl "PvP" anymore, and I don't think I ever will.

 

Although I agree something new should be added I disagree with getting speed pots while on a KS. If everybody but tank had the ability to use speed then what would be the point of the kits that are special because they have speed e.g. Archer. I also don't think Archer's should get any higher speed boost. It may be fun but there would be no way to kill an Archer with Speed 3 unless you got a decent combo. Maps, I actually like the map we currently have as it's simple and definitely suits its purpose for what KitPVP is. I do agree more kits should be added (perhaps taking some ideas from HG.) With newer kits I feel like it would be more fun to play and overall 1v1. This is just my personal opinion but good ideas.

 

50-70 Kits... thats pure ridiculous. 90% of the hits that are in HG can't be applied to a Kit PvP server since they involve editing terrain or similar - It would make the server far to complex.

At the moment it is nice and simple with 1 map for FFA.I agree, the /challenge map isn't actually that good due to the bumpy ground, but the Kit PvP server isn't popular enough to try and be like some of the huge Kit PvP servers which select a random map for ever 1v1.

Speed pots for KS is not a good idea, the kits are balanced (mostly) and I think you will be surprised on how much speed can change PvP, which can unbalance the current setup. Also being able to buy soups in the arena. That would ruin the part where you get 5 more soups for every kill and would make people be able to tank because they can just jump in with a full inventory of soups. The whole point is you work up kills to get the soups - Its a common fact that if you are good at soup PvP, you should be able to survive as long as you have soups. What you suggested will make someone invincible (if their good).

Review is 100% correct. Brawls hit detection is frankly terrible, once you start to get a combo on someone it basically gives you 'hit detection favour' where it is harder for the other player to hit you. This is not just on Kit PvP, it is across all the servers (I think), certainly Survival PvP. I think if Brawl fixed its hit detection it would be much better. When someone asks me for a 1v1 while i'm on Brawl, I rarely say: 'ok, lets go to Kit PvP, do /play kitpvp', instead I say 'Ok, go to [Insert Kit PvP server]'. For the simple reason that Brawls hit detection is horrible.

 

Okay this is a little overboard.... I have never seen a KitPvP do this. Ever.
You have to consider the consequences and costs to doing all this.... How much time would it take to make all these maps? To code this new fighting and souping? To code all these new kits?

1. It's much more reasonable to say an additional map, let's say, that isn't a Colosseum.
2.And no, unless you want to break KitPvP more than it already is, you should not add speed potions. People will constantly complain about either: A. The speed potion screwing up their hotkey or B. Not being able to fight because of how fast they're going.
3. I somewhat agree that we should have some fun kits in the mix, but 50-70 is wayyyy too many. 10-15 should be plenty; and if you want to add kits similar to HG kits, then you should probably have those only available on the secondary map. People [Regulars] will just complain about all these new kits jacking up their time on the normal arena.
4. That's exactly how everyone else does it, and it works just fine.

 

As @SoCool21 said, KitBrawl 2 is pretty much completely done and I'm just waiting on some things before release. I'll answer some of the concerns though.

15-20 different maps is a bit much but I did make a request for more maps in a different style. The ability to select a specific map is initially planned to be a rank perk.

Everyone else already pretty accurately summed up my thoughts here. Feel free to make suggestions for new kits that would fit in with KitBrawl, though.

A whole bunch more 1v1 types are definitely being added.

Unfortunately, I have no control over this. (I'm not going to blatantly remove the anti-cheat and create more work for the mods, for example)