Idea Invisibility has Invincability

The point of invisibility is to not be seen, not to be invincible. Ninjas are currently invulnerable to meelee attacks when invisible but can be hit by projectiles.
Making ninja completely invincible while invis would be a huge problem.

 

I agree with @GalaThundR

 

-

 

If anything I would say ninjas should be weak to melee. Invisibility dust should do exactly what it states, makes the player invisible. There's nothing to suggest it's invulnerability powder. That would of course be a nerf on a class that doesn't need it however. I definitely don't think it should be invincible too.

 

The "agree" rating exists for a reason.

This idea, if implemented, would be complete BS.
On fire? Oh hey, use like 10 dust and nullify it.
Poisoned? Oh no my 10 dust! What a shame!
Engineers would be weak af.
Annoying archer? Stand in front of them, invisible, so all their arrows don't do anything. (afaik it's pretty hard to make projectiles pass through some players).

 

Although I think ninja should still be vulnerable to projectiles, I think it would be a neat idea for ninja to not trigger engineer auto-aim.

 

It's the main reason why Chemist and Pyro are effective against Ninja - they can find them if they happen to see them disappear.

 

While actually playing I remembered something I commonly do while holding as chemist: splashing down poison pots to detect invisible ninjas.
I don't know how it would work in that situation, but both possibilities are really unfair:
1) You get poisoned but the ninja doesn't. Yay free damage for no reason!
2) Nothing happens. Defeats the purpose of the poison pots in this situation and you still get jumped on.

 

Ninja's are so powerful and annoying they should be hit by anything when invisible

 

That would make it severely underpowered.

 

Good xD