Complete skytown

informative and useful post November thank you for contributing

 

+10000000000 for this change alone

 

I helped with the bridge so I give it a like because the bridge looks cool

 

-

 

I don't really like this. It seems to just be Skyworlds, Clockower IV, and Slums smushed together. The buildings are pretty cluttered and will make pvp annoying, the overall color scheme is very bland with it all being brown, and the overall gameplay issue of classes like soldier, elf, etc being able to escape most classes very easily.

If you remove some of the buildings and add more color and block variations to the rest it would be a lot nicer.

 

Gud map 10/10 will play

 

looks dope and the concept is pretty neat but I don't think gameplay would work very well. I still like it tho +1

 

I have concerns about building navigability. I think a lot of people might end up running straight down mid... but it might work out. Could you possibly add sponges at the bottoms of a couple more ladders? I'm lazy and chasing soldiers sucks.

More of the corners of the railing on buildings could use slabs to make it easier to get up without having to run 6 blocks over for a step.

Also, a couple sponges are either short half the time or barely making it to the top at 99% gamespeed. It's hard to measure sponges when there's lag on build because they make you go higher. Could you double check them on an empty server?

Beautiful map, though.

 

Now all it needs is no restrictions and it could replace slums 9.9/10

 

Looks like soldier would cap 9/10 if it got out of flag room because mid has so many buildings. I shouldn't complain because I sort of soldier main but other than being a little soldier op, the map looks pretty balanced and has enough archer cover. Great job!

 

nice

 

I have some problems with the map

#1 as you can see here there's an extra entrance to the flagroom, it's already very easy to get in the Original Skyworlds flagroom so I don't really get why you're making it even easier by having another entrance. In the current meta open flagrooms are terrible for defences that don't consist of a really good pyro and some heavies. Either move it more to the sides so you don't get to run straight in to the flagroom.


#2 Can't really blame you for this cuz in Original skyworlds the problem existed as well.
However it is very unlikely to happen, the flagroom is headshottable. And there are plenty of archers who dare to go offensive in order to support their offense, and they could take out a pyro/assassin/whatsoever that is standing next to the flagroom in no time. It's not your fault but I'd like to see this minor problem solved.



#3a I have some issues with the height of the buildings. They make soldier a ridiculous overpowered class and without ninjas who are good with pearls or soldiers who manage to turn around and catch up to the other team's flag carrier there is barely any chance of recovery. You have placed many sponges yes but a soldier with buffs is faster than anything else (apart from ninja and assassin) with buffs and sponges. It's mobility is ridiculously overpowered because of the many buildings.

#3b The height of the building takes out the archer aspect on Skyworlds. I agree that Skyworlds I is pretty archer op but you almost completely nerfed archer in my opinion. Archer has to stay near their spawn (eg pic 1) in order to get a good view over the map, most of the different paths are covered in buildings and offer protection from the archers. However, an archer camping near spawn is hard to kill meaning that once you have stolen it's hard to get the archer + with the spawn literally being right next to what is most likely going to be the archers position your attempt to capture is at greater risk for the first 20 blocks within the archers range. But basically after you've dodged the archer, it's a class of no use anymore. In general I would just like to see a couple less buildings and a little bit lower to lower the soldier's mobility and slightly increase the archer's capacities up to 50% of the map being in sight and if with a good shot, possibly headshottable.

Apart from these 3 "problems" cool map, keep up the good work please

 

Thank you for clarifying would still lowkey like to see the buildings a block or 5 lower