Idea (Class Idea) Guardian

10 god apples is far too op. Sharpness 5 diamond axe would given it the best damage output in the game and the armour is the 2nd best after heavy. No, far too op.

 

I agree with sporty man that this class is far too op. Furthermore, this class doesn't add anything to the game itself. All it is is an super buffed heavy. So -1.

 

There's not a -1 section of your poll ._.

Compared to the other classes this would be so ridiculously over powered.... like what?

I want to believe that you're serious (correct me if this is a joke) so, I think you should look at the other classes and think of something similar, something that would fit in the current meta. No new classes are really needed, but if you're set on getting one added, think a little more realistically.

 

Fire protection does not make you immune to being lit on fire/axed by pyros.

 

As a defensive class, this class lacks the ability to protect itself from assassins. Unless you plan to add passive assassination resistance, this class must have at least a wooden sword in addition to the axe to protect it from assassins. Leaving a pure defensive class susceptible to assassinations is one of the worst decisions that can be made for a defensive class.

Not having any steak, or at least a way to regenerate health is an extremely bad decision for any class type, let alone a defensive class. All classes have some form of health regeneration, and not having any steak to 'balance' out the class simply serves to make it underpowered and will result in it being underplayed.

The immunity to pyro's fire is a good idea, however pyro is a defensive class that is rarely, if ever, used on offence. This resistance to fire would be better suited on an offensive class, where it would be more likely to run into a pyro. This ability is essentially useless on a defensive class.

Knockback stick is good for a defensive class, as is the armor.

As for the weapon, what do you mean by a 'buffer period' after two successful hits? Does it apply a debuff? Does it mean they can't attack for x number of seconds? If so, how long does the ability last? This needs to be thoroughly explained.

A class idea must be thoroughly thought out before it can be considered a full blown class idea. When you are finished with it, it should look like the description of a class that's already playable in CTF. If it does not, it needs more work. This idea looks like it has a lot of good ideas that were cobbled together in approximately 15 minutes. If this were a class concept, and you were looking for feedback on a general idea before creating the class, this would be perfectly acceptable. However, as this is supposed to be a fully developed class idea, I can't let any of these issues slide.

Work on bringing all of your ideas together so they fit into a singular class, as well as ensuring that you think of all possible abilities that you want this class to have, and develop them fully. Then, it could easily be a great class idea. Until that happens, -1.

 

Maybe do this:
Slowness 1
Iron Armor and a leather Chestplate
Knock 2 stick and Diamond Axe(not enchanted)
3 steak