Other 2018 Map Wave Submissions

Can't wait to test these maps !

 

how long do we have i will build a top tier map in 3 days watch me

 

@Xelasi are these not allowed? :O
https://www.brawl.com/threads/67912/
https://www.brawl.com/threads/67927/

 

woah who did one of those sexy renders o.o

 

Spoiler: Thoughts

Original Maps:

141369 Battle of Geonosis by @maniwo
-1: Too big, underground is confusing

390153 Canyons by @juyy, _K2
-1, too small

369836 Cliff Palace by @Daveeeeeeeee
+1, looks great, path between flags is quite short though – I’d block off the front exit

371027 Cyberspace by @MichaelS01
-1, map too big, too easy to get lost, map consists entirely of narrow tunnels that don’t make for good gameplay

370666 Futuristic City by @RedwolfWarrior
+1, looks great, flagroom looks a bit easy to escape from though. Also, isn’t this a rework of Tuscan City?

369428 Grass Strike I by @HelpMeee , Pugily
-1, needs more obstacles/tunnels.

400329 Medieval Warfare by @ThatOneGamer999, NightWolfPlays
+0, seems pretty Soldier/Ninja OP, weird flag placement and spawn is unfinished, probably fine for testing though

332124 Modern Diversity by @Ducksfan101
+1, looks awesome. Paths look a bit odd though, and I’m not sure what the cars are doing there lol

242151 Ravine Ruins by @November
+1, flagroom seems a bit easy to defend though

356913 Rift by @_featherpaw_, Chilled_67, Fordale
+1 Siege!!! No complaints

331768 Riot by @Shawn_
+1, interesting map, fun to explore. Aesthetics could maybe do with a bit of work

377064 Sunstar by @Dokkedal
+0 flagroom is definitely too easy to defend, looks great otherwise

388152 The Great Wall by @olitree
+0: flagroom also too easy to defend, blue trees look crap

332125 Versailles by @Evan19119
+1, looks dope

Reworks:

404518 Beaver Creek V by @Daveeeeeeeee
+0: looks great, not sure if changes are enough to fix awful gameplay, but I’m willing to try it out

360870 Capture II by @pandaniel_ow
+1, fixed all the horrible problems with the original

401547 Citadel II by @Creeperflame
-1, still way too soldier op, difficult to cap or recover with any other class

387559 Divinity's Reach V by @Insomniac__
+1 Love it!!!

383891 Metro I by @puhdgy
+1 I’ve always found Metro slightly confusing – this seems a bit better but I’d still remove the superfluous corner areas

360791 Metro I by @pandaniel_ow
+1 I think I prefer this version since it’s smaller so it’s less confusing. I’d still flip the orientation of the spawn room though, so you’re not facing backwards when you spawn

393244 Parthenon III by @Shadoun
+0 I don’t think this fixes the problems of the original, it still looks soldier op

332126 Platforms Reborn by @puhdgy @Aykaka @Ducksfan101 @Daveeeeeeeee
+1: Definitely better than the original, but I’m not sure by how much. Soldiers and Ninjas are still going to be the best option for capping, but other classes will have a better chance of stealing. Could be added to rotation no problem. Looks great too.

389315 Quintet Falls I by @LeUniCow
+1, significant improvement to the original

390154 Ship Battle 2.0 by @olitree
+1. Tentative +1, this is another one that’s better than the original but probably not by much. Worth testing at least

389443 Treeline I by @Kashyyyk
+1, definite improvement over the original, would love to try it out

 

@rhoske Can you specify what paths look odd so I can look into changing them? Also the cars were there to add cover and just to be there.

 

The granite and dirt ones, just personal preference tho

 

both actually lol

 

Will fix later thank you^^

 

did the spawn thing =)

 

ok lads i will accept the challenge i will build another top tier (skytown haha) map in 3 days I will start thursday-friday

 

I have made some modifications. Feel free to look at it now and see if it is better