Complete Argonne Forest

Very raw - ain't pretty or extravagant but it encapsulates how structures and the environment were during war or legit ctf BATTLES

I'll definitely want to check it out ingame later and I can give u better feedback through that

 

I‘m not too sure...I played Battlefield 1 a lot a few months ago and this doesn‘t really capture that close quarters insanity that gun combat provides on the map, you also don‘t have any special turrets or anything to use. I think a more close-knit map with some good Engi spots and some opener areas would make this map better (only 2 pictures loaded for me so I might have missed something).

 

I've checked the map out in game and this is definitely going to be a -1 from me.

Cons:
- You have grass (tall grass) everywhere, this means that PvP would be pretty bad as you'd constantly be hitting that instead of the player. You could probably remove 90% of it and keep patches of it on hilly areas where players are less likely to PvP.

- Flagroom seems very confusing and quite easy to get lost in. Could probably remove 1 or 2 of the entrances and make it simpler for newer players. You also don't need to have the water in the flagroom as pyro really isn't that op anymore and it just gets in the way. It'd also be a very op camping spot for stalemates.

- Map is cluttered with holes and trees which will also affect PvP. I assume you added it for archer cover and to better represent the thing you are basing the map off however there are way too many trees, holes and other things. Could probably get rid of atleast half of them to be honest. It's also fairly op for soldier because of this but I understand it is hard to get the right balance with archer and soldier.

- Aesthetics could be improved a lot but that isn't a big deal, for example you could make custom trees instead of the Minecraft generated ones.

Pros:
- I like the idea of the map and I think it could have just been executed better.

- Spawn seems to be a good distance from your own teams flag, you can't get back too quickly but you can still get there reasonably fast.

- Archer isn't really hugely op on this map except for a few spots on hills for example.