Complete Quintet Falls I

I really like what you did with this map. I love that you moved spawn and didn't change too much of the gameplay, which I appreciate because it offers unique/interesting gameplay. If I'm being nitpicky(which I am for this), I think making the sign face in this direction would be better, just so you can see both exits in spawn:


If there's anything big for me that I'm a bit sad to not have seen changed, it'd be the middle castle. It's not exactly that I mind the height or its presence, but I do mind the archer sight lines you can get from just standing on it, you get a view of a large amount of the map. Spawn shooting may be a concern.


Overall +1, I'd love to see it in testing. Nice job

 

First of all, I like this rework a lot as you have definitely improved most of the flaws from the original. There are also additions that you have added such as the sponge in the spawn tower above, which is a neat shortcut for travelling to mid quicker, and the path underneath the middle bridge which can be used to avoid any headshots whilst going across the middle part of the map. However, in my opinion I have a few, small concerns about this map, such as:

• The flagroom still remains in a claustrophobic look and feeling. This bothers me because as an offensive main, I feel that I will suffer with this enclosed flagroom as well as my other offensive teammates. I guess this is a more defensive biased map which I don't hate, but the flagroom could be more spacious.
• This is very nitpicky but I don't like the trapdoors located above the four sponges in the flagroom corners. Most of the time they restrict me leaving/entering the flagroom quickly, which may be a problem if I was a flag carrier. You could say that I can avoid hitting my head on the trap door, however if you are carrying a flag you would be wanting to leave the flagroom as quickly as possible and your focus at that moment isn't avoiding the trapdoor, your focus is trying to escape. Remove the trapdoors to fix this.
• This final concern is what @puhdgy mentioned above: the middle castle. I agree with her; the archer sight lines you get from just standing on it will be a huge pain for offensive players. Also, spawn shooting may occur like @puhdgy mentioned too.

Overall +1, it is a great rework and I would love to see it in testing. Good luck!