Personal CTF Wishlist

Omg Hahaha, one ninja and every pyro in the Flagroom is dead.

I just want the old pyro back, not a new rework to more ****.
That is the truth.

 

You might as well remove dwarf if you're going to take away its only defense against assassin

 

actually like this rework from necro, this would be a bit more useful in the competetive scene then currently

 

I havent been here in a while? has archer been nerfed? does it still instakill past 30 blocks? I ask only cause i didnt see it on the reworks

 

No, with 3 steaks the pyro is dead>insta, like his instakill kills insta.
5 Steaks and everything would be fine.

 

I really like these ideas. Infinite wall climb is way more fun and having a cooldown isn't necessary, it is just an useless restriction. The assassinate change would make it easier for an assassin to kill a soldier. At the moment, it's really hard to assassinate a soldier (for me at least) because most of the time they are just wall climbing or are just too far/high away.

I like this idea but I don't think it is really necessary and it probably won't do much. I mean, if you use the sugar because you are going to assassinate, then if someone hits you, they insta kill you so the knockback doesn't matter. If you just use the sugar to go somewhere faster then nobody should be able to hit you as you can escape anyone with speed III, except for ninjas but taking no knockback won't stop them to kill you haha. It can still be a bit useful in certain situations though, but not worth it because taking no knockback would confuse a lot of people, especially new players who would think you are just cheating.

This rework would make dwarf not viable at all for a good defense as it would die to any assassin. However, it would encourage a lot of new players (potential regulars) to play it because they think it's OP and they would actually have a lot more fun playing it.

I'm not a fan at all of instakills. If pyro were to be reworked I think we should buff it but in a different way. The insta kill would be frustrating for many players as it oneshots them without any chance for them to avoid that but the pyro would die to almost every ninja, making the class weak to an organized offense but annoying xD.

I think engineer has nothing to do in CTF. However, as I guess it won't be removed, I prefer the class to have more things that advantage your team than things that annoy the opposite team. Therefore, in my opinion the changes are great as they make the class more fun to play but also makes life easier for its teammates.

For necro I like these suggestions because they make the class easier to play and more useful. It would now be able to target specific players especially flag carriers, which would make the class more focused on the objective as before.

 

Just delete the game and replace it with minecraft version of raving rabbids

 

Although some of these ideas could really help out the game (I like the soldier ones especially), reverting many of the class updates over the years isn't the way to go imo. These changes were implemented for good reason at the time and I don't think they should be removed because some players are nostalgic about their favourite classes being strong. Sure, pyro was really fun for pyro mains, but many offence players didn't like having 0 counterplay - especially newer ones.

I'm not saying that every past change made needs to be kept forever, but we need to ask why it was changed in the first place. For example - having infinite soldier wallclimb may make the class more enjoyable and easy to pick up, but the downside could be very long stalemates and map abusing.

I like the Necro change though - I feel like it brings together the best aspects of several reworks.

 

yes it still does instakill past 30 blocks

 

still good in this game then. Poggers

 

Infinite wall climb is good for laggy players who need to waste all their wallclimb just to get up onto the Blackout flagroom.

 

Your reworks literally involve reverting pyro, engineer and soldier back to the mcpvp state. There was a reason they were changed in the first place. Your assassin fix doesn't address the problem you indicated.
Do I agree some of these classes need changing? yes.
Do I think that these reworks are any good? absolutely not.

 

Making classes more powerful and reverting classes are not the same thing. We already changed those classes to their current "nerfed" state specifically because there were problems. We'd have the same complaints we had on mcpvp if we were to revert them, hence why I agreed they should be changed, but these solutions weren't the answer.
For the record, a "scrub" as you put it could pick up and play any class currently. They just may not necessarily play it well.

 

Just delete Necro problem sovled

 

These are very nice, I hope that the necro change actually happens because it's amazing. Necro can be a more used class.
For a dwarf, you shouldn't remove their sword, it's already an underplayed class. Removing the sword and replacing it with an axe would just make dwarves work for their level and then get assassinated and have no way to defend themselves asides hitting first.
Pyro, to be honest the current pyro is working well and is fun to play. The old pyro is still fun but it might be a bit unfair to other classes because lighting someone on fire is pretty easy, but instakilling was fun.